1. Identify the sample before evaluating it
Give each sample a reference code. Record its proposed dimensions, thickness, material description, printing and packing format, together with the date received. Ask whether it represents the intended production specification or only an example of a format. This distinction matters when a sample uses different artwork, a different closure or a different material from the proposed order.
2. Check dimensions and practical fit
Measure the agreed reference points and record your method. For a bin liner, use the intended bin and note how the opening sits over the rim. For garment packaging, try the relevant folded item. For a mailer, check the packed item and closure area. Do not rely on the printed capacity or a photograph when a physical fit check is possible.
3. Review opening, separation and closure
Check how the bag opens, how a roll separates and how any closure is used. Repeat the handling steps in the way the customer or packing operator is expected to perform them. Record difficulties clearly: where the issue occurs, how frequently it appeared in your review and whether another sample behaved differently.
| Review area | Record the result |
|---|---|
| Identity | Sample reference and proposed specification |
| Fit | Test item or bin, measurements and observations |
| Handling | Opening, separation, closure and carrying steps |
| Packing | Count, presentation and identification |
| Documents | Outstanding questions for the proposed product |
4. Agree a relevant handling trial
Choose a representative load and handling sequence with the supplier. Define the number of samples, the loading method and what would count as an acceptable result before comparing options. Use safe, controlled conditions and document the trial. A casual demonstration or one successful lift should not be turned into a universal load or leak-resistance claim.
5. Inspect print and packing
Review legibility, artwork placement and the information shown on the bag, retail pack and carton. Check the unit counts against the proposed quotation. Identify whether the observed artwork is final or illustrative. Where environmental claims or marks are proposed, keep the document review separate from the visual approval.
6. Close the review with a decision
Classify each issue as accepted, revision requested or information needed. Send specific feedback with photographs and reference codes. If a revision changes the proposed specification, ask which points should be reviewed again. Retain an accepted reference sample where practical and save the written approval with the order records.
Before production approval, confirm that the quotation, specification, artwork and packing instructions describe the same option. This final comparison gives the sample review a clear outcome and creates a useful reference for a repeat order.
Planning a sample review? Request samples and explain the application you want to evaluate. For evidence questions, use Quality & Documents; for a proposed order, send your requirements.
Related Resources
Dog Poop Bag Rolls for Pet Brands and Distributors
Sample Decision Record to Copy
Fill in the fields you know. Keep unanswered items as questions. This is a project worksheet, not a test certificate or an order approval.
The delivered bags differ from the approved sample. Which cartons should you hold?
When a delivery fails a packing step, keep the first affected carton and its label together. Start with a narrow question you can reproduce. For instance, does the first bag tear below the perforation when an operator removes it from the roll?
Check what the approval covered
Match the retained sample to the signed specification, revision and purchase order. An early colour sample may have a different perforation from the version approved for production. At receiving, record the product reference and the lot from each outer carton. If the label uses GS1 identifiers, the field marked (10) is the batch or lot number. Photograph any unfamiliar code and ask the supplier to identify it.
Separate a roll problem from a dispenser problem
For a bench check, run the retained roll and one affected roll through the same dispenser, in the same feed direction. Record the tear position and how many times it recurs. Then try the affected roll in a second compatible dispenser. A tear that follows the roll calls for a different supplier investigation from a tear that only appears at one damaged outlet.
Give receiving an actionable decision
Label the suspect stock and pause issue of cartons with the implicated lot while the parties review the evidence. Keep unidentified cartons separate until their lot is confirmed. Send the number of rolls actually inspected, affected carton IDs, photographs and the requested next step. A few trial rolls cannot establish a defect percentage for the entire shipment. Record who authorizes release, replacement or further inspection for each lot.